Untangling the Caucasian knot

For the second time since 2004’s Beslan tragedy, the Kremlin is taking strong measures to end violence in the North Caucasus. Krasnoyarsk governor Alexander Khloponin is now presidential envoy to the new North Caucasus Federal District. He was also appointed deputy prime minister.

The biggest novelty in Khloponin’s appointment is that by combining the posts of presidential envoy and deputy prime minister, he will have to answer to both Vladimir Putin and Dmitry Medvedev. This makes sense. Of all the regions, Prime Minister Putin has always been most concerned about the Southern Federal District, just ahead of the Far East Federal District in his list of priorities. The envoys of these two regions have been dropped and reappointed more frequently than in any other regions.

By choosing Khloponin, the Kremlin has opted for a business rather than a siloviki model. It has decided that it would make sense to apply Khloponin’s Krasnoyarsk business plan to another region badly in need of investment and efficient management.

The new North Caucasus Federal District



The Krasnoyarsk region is renowned for its successful leadership under Khloponin. It outperformed Moscow and St Petersburg in terms of attracting investment in 2007, a remarkable accomplishment for a remote region, albeit one rich in natural resources. It is also noteworthy that one of Russia’s largest economic forums is held in Krasnoyarsk every year.

In recent years, the government in the Krasnoyarsk region has become a training ground for the export of effective managers. A former head of the Krasnoyarsk government, Alexander Novak, serves as a deputy to finance minister Alexei Kudrin, and is charged with supervising major federal programmes. Former deputy governor Anatoly Tikhonov became first deputy chairman of Vneshekonombank responsible for major investment projects. And deputy governor Sergei Sokol was once sent to strengthen the Irkutsk administration and is now a strong candidate for a gubernatorial post in another region.

Putin is a big fan of Khloponin. The prime minister supported him in the disputed gubernatorial election in 2002, and Putin reappointed him as governor in 2007. Also, Khloponin is a classmate and friend of pro-modernisation oligarch Mikhail Prokhorov. Ambitious and eager to rise through the ranks, Khloponin has long been discussed as a candidate for a high-ranking position in Moscow.

There is no doubt that Khloponin is highly effective as a crisis manager. He has strong business experience and connections, understands the institutions needed for development and how to use them, and knows how to rely on a qualified team for support. But those skills alone are no guarantee of success at his new post. Although Khloponin has a strong track record in attracting large investment projects, ensuring the proper and transparent expenditure of funds and battling corruption, his expertise and personality do not match the previous presidential envoys to the region in dealing with the deeply rooted tensions and conflicts between various ethnic groups and clans, as well as extremism in the North Caucasus.

As envoy to the North Caucasus Federal District, Khloponin will face a Herculean managerial task that is split between three levels: at the top, navigating between Putin, Medvedev, federal ministers and the Kremlin; at the bottom, handling the tricky relations with North Caucasus leaders; and in the middle, trying to bring his own team aboard.

I am concerned that the interests of the various influential groups in both Moscow and the region are too much at odds – or in outright conflict – for Khloponin to cope with them effectively, no matter how much independent authority and power he is given.

Much will become clear during his first months on the job, when Khloponin, a young, aggressive and modern manager, will have to establish relations with conservative North Caucasus leaders. Will he be perceived as a brash, upstart Moscow emissary and coldly accepted by Chechen president Ramzan Kadyrov and other leaders in the region?

In the Caucasus, after all, it is usually conservative military types, such as Kadyrov – who was recently promoted to general – who carry the most weight.

The refined, Moscow-bred Khloponin was excellent at running Norilsk Nickel while in his 30s. Let’s hope that he can achieve the same level of success in the North Caucasus.

Nikolai Petrov is a scholar in residence at the Carnegie Moscow Centre

All rights reserved by Rossiyskaya Gazeta.