Could Russia be deprived of 2018 World Cup over latest FIFA scandal?

Russian football team in training session ahead of Euro 2016 Qualifier, Sept. 3. 2015. Source: Vasily Ponomarev/TASS

Russian football team in training session ahead of Euro 2016 Qualifier, Sept. 3. 2015. Source: Vasily Ponomarev/TASS

Vasily Ponomarev / TASS
Despite new fears over the future of the 2018 World Cup in Russia after FIFA President Sepp Blatter and UEFA boss Michel Platini were banned from soccer for 90 days, Russian experts do not believe that the latest scandal to hit football’s corruption-plagued governing body will affect the tournament.

Questions are once more swirling about the future of the 2018 FIFA World Cup in Russia after the president of soccer’s international governing body Joseph “Sepp” Blatter and head of the European football organization UEFA Michel Platini were banned from football for 90 days on Oct. 8.

Now the officials are not only prohibited from coming to their own offices, but also from taking on any job related to the sport.

The decision was made by the FIFA ethics committee after having begun an internal investigation into the officials on Sept. 26. A day earlier the Swiss Federal Justice Bureau opened a criminal case against Blatter, who is suspected of negligence and theft, as well as of giving Platini bribes.

The investigation is continuing but so far no accusations have been made against Platini and Blatter. If necessary, their disqualification can be extended for another 45 days.

FIFA has spent much of the last few years mired in accusations of corruption, with the decisions to award the 2018 and 2022 World Cups to Russia and Qatar widely seen by global media and senior figures within the sport as having been conducted unfairly, with suspicions of bribery continuing to hang over the process.

 

Russia is not under suspicion

Sports lawyer Valery Fedoreyev says the ethics committee has made the right decision but does not believe that the investigation will have “any impact” on Russia.

“In order to take away the World Cup from Russia the decision must be made at the level of the FIFA Congress,” said Fedoreyev. “So even if Blatter is found guilty of corruption, this will not affect Russia. The investigation does not include Russia, or Qatar.”

He added that an internal FIFA investigation had found no evidence of wrongdoing in the voting process for the two tournaments.

 

Could economic reasons have an effect?

There has been only one time in the history of soccer to date when a hosting country was deprived of the World Cup. In 1984 Colombia was forced to forfeit the 1986 tournament for economic reasons and the championship was transferred to Mexico, which had already hosted it in 1970.

Football expert and Vice President of the International Foundation of Legal Initiatives Alisher Aminov believes that given its current position Russia should follow in Colombia's footsteps, independently of Platini and Blatter's fates.

"Blatter and Platini's reputations are under threat. Russia is not affected by this process and the championships will take place. But in the context of the economic and political situation this entire story is creating mixed feelings,” he said.

“The mad expenses on soccer and the possibility of a social explosion – these are phenomena from the same reality. In the conditions of political isolation and with the Russian banking system on the verge of collapse, these enormous expenses on the World Cup are self-destructive.”

Deputy Sports Minister Yury Nagornykh does not agree with Aminov: "We are completely realizing all the plans concerning infrastructure construction and are respecting the budget. Which is why talk about opting out of holding such a prestigious tournament looks groundless. As for Blatter, no accusations have been made against him. It is not excluded that very soon the prosecutors will close the case."

 

Is Platini still in the game?

The new FIFA presidential elections are set for Feb. 26. By then Platini's disqualification will have ended, but a special FIFA committee will have to confirm the candidature of the main contender for the presidential seat, conducting an additional check on the Frenchman.

In the view of Valery Chukhry, ex-director of FIFA's Moscow's office, Platini is the only person who can create order within FIFA. Chukhry is also certain that the UEFA president views Russia in a positive light.

"Just take the story of Crimea for example, when UEFA was able in this extremely difficult situation to respect the interests of all sides, demonstrating [its] equidistance from all political forces. [In view of the disagreement over Crimea's political status UEFA has decided to create a separate championship on the peninsula – RBTH] Also, St. Petersburg has received [some] Euro 2020 matches. When Platini was pressured to impose maximum sanctions on Russia, he adhered to the sporting principle."

Besides Platini, former World Cup winner Diego Maradona is also running for the position of FIFA president, as well as Brazilian footballing legend Zico, Jordanian Prince Ali bin Al-Hussein and Head of the Liberia Football Association Musa Bility.

All rights reserved by Rossiyskaya Gazeta.

More exciting stories and videos on Russia Beyond's Facebook page

This website uses cookies. Click here to find out more.

Accept cookies